Skip to main content
How New Agents Can Build Trust & Book Appointments Fast
Starting your insurance career is exciting… and a little intimidating.
Most new agents ask: “Where do I find my first customer?”
The truth is, you don’t need to know thousands of people or have a huge following to succeed. You just need to understand how to show up in the right markets — with the right message.
Let’s break down how you can build relationships in your warm, cold, and unknown markets, and how to use Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, and TikTok to turn strangers into clients.
1. Warm Market – Start With the People Who Already Know You
Your warm market includes family, friends, past coworkers, church members, your barber — anyone who knows your name and has a general level of trust.
How to Be Seen as the Professional:
- Let them know you’re licensed and what you help people with
- Share client success stories or testimonials (even if from your team at first)
- Host a free “Family Finance Night” on Zoom and invite them
- Be consistent, not pushy — show up as a resource, not a salesperson
What You Can Do Today:
Send a simple message:
“Hey [Name], I just got licensed and I’m helping families protect their income and prepare for the future. If you ever want to chat or know someone who might, I’d love to help.”
Post a short story on Facebook or IG about why you became an agent — make it personal, not pitchy.
2. Cold Market – Build Trust With People You’ve Never Met
Your cold market is everyone you don’t know — yet. People on social media, referrals, people you meet at events, or leads you get from marketing.
How to Be Seen as the Professional:
- Position yourself as an educator — not a seller
- Use short videos or carousels to explain common questions (ex: “What’s the difference between term and whole life?”)
- Offer free value, like downloadable checklists or policy reviews
- Respond to DMs and comments with curiosity and care
What You Can Do Today:
- Post on TikTok or Reels:
- “3 things I didn’t know about life insurance until I became licensed.”
- Add a link to your bio that says:
- “Book a free consultation | Learn how to protect what matters most”
- Use Facebook groups, LinkedIn DMs, and story polls to start conversations that feel real, not robotic.
3. Unknown Market – Get Found Without Reaching Out
The unknown market is when strangers find you first — through your content, referrals, or online presence. This is where brand positioning pays off.
How to Be Seen as the Professional:
- Keep your Instagram, LinkedIn, and TikTok bios clean and clear (example: “Helping families plan financially | Book a free call below”)
- Post stories about your mission, wins, challenges, and tips
- Show your face. Be the agent they recognize before they even meet you.
- Add testimonials, FAQs, and simple appointment links
What You Can Do Today:
Post 3 times this week:
- One story (why you became an agent)
- One educational tip (ex: “What happens if you get cancer with no coverage?”)
- One lifestyle post (behind the scenes, showing you working or on Zoom)
Update your LinkedIn headline:
“Licensed Insurance Agent | Helping families & professionals protect what matters | Book a free call ☎️”
Social Media Tips by Platform
Instagram:
- Use Reels and Stories with captions
- Post 3–4 times a week (face, tips, wins, mission)
- DM people who engage with you — not to sell, but to start conversations
Facebook:
- Use your personal profile to build warm connections
- Go Live once a week sharing value or answering questions
- Join local groups or parenting forums and add value
LinkedIn:
- Focus on professionals and business owners
- Post finance, retirement, or insurance-related education
- Use polls or DMs to ask “Are you planning for retirement?” or “Do you have a backup plan if income stops?”
TikTok:
- Use 15–60 second videos to share quick tips
- Don’t be afraid to show personality
- Consistency wins — one viral video can change your business
You Don’t Need 10,000 Followers — You Need Trust
The most successful agents aren’t the loudest.
They’re the ones who listen, who show up, and who treat every prospect like someone worth protecting.
Your first client is out there right now — waiting for someone like you to show up and care enough to educate them.
📞 Book a Strategy Call and learn how we help new agents start strong, build relationships, and find clients without begging friends or cold calling strangers.
